Moderated by: Brian Wagner, IEBA
Panelists: Craig Baltzer, The Monument · Craig Hassall, Playhouse Square · Michael Mariano, Tourism Economics · Sarah Pancheri, Milwaukee World Festival / Summerfest · Greg Pepitone, Tourism Economics
Brian Wagner framed the session as another way IEBA is building value for its members, right after Roster’s Vivian Donahue introduced a new promoter directory and a growing partnership with IEBA that includes a job board and subscriptions for scholarship recipients. Wagner spent most of a career in venue management and concert promotion before seven years with the Tennessee state tourism department, working with economists on studies from the state level down to individual counties. That is where Wagner met Tourism Economics, which took over state economic impact studies for all 50 states during that time. “There’s just not great data for the live entertainment industry as a whole,” Wagner said, so IEBA developed a program that gives members a discount on economic impact studies with the firm.
Who Tourism Economics Is
Michael Mariano, who heads the economic development team, said Tourism Economics is a subsidiary of Oxford Economics, a team of about 700 economists worldwide. Tourism Economics itself has about 100 economists, data analysts and industry experts across the U.S., Asia and Europe. Mariano said the team prides itself on not being typical data geeks. Senior staff include a former professional soccer player, a former professional bowler and a DJ and sound engineer, which helps them tell the difference between the spending patterns of “a Backstreet Boys concert versus a Beyoncé concert, a World Series game, or an orchestral performance.”
Greg Pepitone walked through a client list that runs from venues like Playhouse Square and the Monument and events like Summerfest to Disney World, museums, zoos, the RNC and DNC and this past summer’s World Cup. Locally, the team worked with the Tennessee Titans on the new enclosed stadium. Most clients use the data for advocacy, Pepitone said, to help justify public funding and to show “what does this do for the quality of life in the local economy?”
How an Impact Study Works
Mariano broke a study into three parts. Direct impact covers a venue’s operating spending plus what attendees spend on site and around town. Indirect impact comes as those businesses buy from their own local suppliers. Induced impact comes as employees of the venue, hotels and restaurants spend their wages locally.
To make it concrete, Mariano asked if there were any BTS Army members in the room, then described a family trip from Philadelphia to Las Vegas with a diehard-fan future mother-in-law for three BTS shows at Allegiant Stadium. The group’s direct spending included about $400 in merchandise, $100 in food and beverage and “thousands of dollars” in tickets, plus a hotel, a steakhouse dinner and numerous Uber rides. The hotel and restaurant buying from their suppliers is indirect impact, and their employees paying rent and buying groceries is induced impact.
Pepitone said each study measures business sales, jobs and wages across 17 sectors, so a venue can tell the lodging industry exactly how much business and how many jobs it supports there. Studies also calculate federal, state and local tax revenue, including sales, lodging and admissions taxes.
The payoff is real. Mariano said the firm has completed more than 200 impact studies, and corrected a typo on the slide. The figure should read $3.6 billion in public and private funding that past clients have received. Its study for Nissan Stadium, going up a few blocks away, helped secure $1.2 billion in public funding, “billion with a B.”
The Monument: Defend Every Number
Craig Baltzer described “a very large property in a very small market.” The Monument in South Dakota includes an 11,000-seat arena, a 6,500-seat arena, a 1,700-seat theater, a field house and convention space, in a town of fewer than 100,000 people that relies heavily on tourism.
“People forget why they build these buildings in the first place,” Baltzer said. Taxpayers and governments usually build them to create economic impact. “Sure, it’s great to talk about the last concert you had, but when it comes down to how well are you really doing, it’s about what are you bringing to town.”
When local politicians said they wouldn’t believe a study’s numbers, Baltzer asked Tourism Economics for an extremely conservative approach. “I can defend every number on that,” Baltzer said. “We went to our city council, we went out to the community with this and nobody could shoot a hole through it.” The goal is to show “that taxpayer that never goes to your venue for anything” why the building matters. The Monument plans a new study in the next year to year and a half.
Wagner added that the tax revenue venues generate often pays for police, roads, health and safety, and education. “I didn’t know putting on all these shows how much I was doing in my community,” Wagner said.
Summerfest: Let People Under the Tent
Sarah Pancheri said Summerfest, which turns 59 next year, runs nine days at the 75-acre Henry Maier Festival Park on the shores of Lake Michigan. Generating $221 million in nine days “is a fact that I will share with anyone that will listen.”
Pancheri uses the numbers with sponsors, donors and civic officials, but also as a pride point for vendors and employees. “This is a moment where you really let people under the tent,” Pancheri said. “The more you can involve people to take part in this and then really share the ownership of the numbers, the better.” Summerfest reports at both the city and state levels, including $15 million in taxes over the nine days. This year’s two-night Garth Brooks kickoff added $30 million in impact on its own, and 48% of ticket buyers came from out of state.
Pancheri’s biggest tip was to let the numbers ladder up. “I would encourage anyone that works with economic impact to talk not about millions, but about billions.” Over 13 years, Summerfest has generated more than $2 billion. Pancheri also urged venues to count direct spending, which since COVID “is not a given.” Echoing Mariano’s BTS trip, “It’s not just the plane, it’s the Uber, it’s the dinners, it’s the poolside margaritas,” and none of it happens “but for that show.”
Playhouse Square: Hard Data, Not Platitudes
Craig Hassall said all three organizations on stage are not-for-profits that exist for their communities. “We can say it, but without data like this, it’s just a platitude.” Hassall likes that the data can be cut many ways. “The more skeptical politicians will only want the first number, but the first number is very compelling.”
The 2019 study Hassall inherited showed about $360 million in annual impact. After hearing a Cleveland colleague use the word “billion” in a presentation, Hassall told the team, “Get those Oxford guys on the phone.” The recut showed more than $4 billion in cumulative impact over about 40 years. “The best thing about it is it’s actually true,” Hassall said.
Playhouse Square runs 12 venues in a footprint of two or three blocks in Cleveland and owns about 2.4 million square feet of real estate, including a hotel and two apartment buildings. Its first study was a consortium with the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, the Cleveland Museum of Art and the Cleveland Orchestra, and Playhouse Square’s annual impact came in at about the same as the other three combined.
The organization uses the data to lobby for historic tax credits and to make its case to trusts, foundations and city council. It also helped win a $5 million rolling carve-out of Ohio’s film and theater tax credit to encourage Broadway producers to launch national tours in the state. Since then, Ohio has hosted tour launches of Tina in Akron, Hell’s Kitchen, The Notebook, Spamalot and Death Becomes Her, with The Who’s Tommy opening in Cleveland next week. Each launch adds four or five weeks of local impact, already about $175 million in direct impact using a Broadway League multiplier.
“I know this could be the most boring session of the whole conference because it’s all about numbers,” Hassall said, “but this stuff is super, super helpful.” Wagner disagreed. “It’s not boring if you do it with an accent.” Hassall previously ran the Royal Albert Hall in London.
From Data to Dollars
Asked for more examples, Pepitone pointed to Tennessee’s major event grant program, where studies have helped events from small gatherings up to the MLB Speedway Classic win state funding.
Baltzer said studies matter after a building opens, not just for the vote that funds it. “What’s important is that we come back and continue to do the studies to show that venue is meeting up to those standards.” Baltzer added that even a local-only event creates impact. “If you’re getting them out on a Wednesday night that they normally wouldn’t go out on, you’re creating economic impact.”
Pancheri said the study was “the first item that we put up on the board” when Summerfest renewed several large gifts at seven-figure levels to keep promoting amphitheater shows. It showed donors how carefully the organization stewards their money.
Hassall said Playhouse Square recently bought a Greyhound bus station. “I don’t know why, because it was there,” Hassall joked. The study helped prove the organization could manage it, unlocking $2 million to preserve the building. The data also convinced Broadway producers that Cleveland could compete with Los Angeles, Atlanta, Boston and Chicago for tour launches.
Mariano added that studies have helped 4,000- to 5,000-seat amphitheaters secure about $20 million in funding. For one confidential venue in the Northwest, a study persuaded the county to help fund sewer service. “It’s not necessarily just funding,” Mariano said.
The Process
With the panel serving as “basically LL Cool J’s opening act,” Wagner kept it moving to the process. Hassall called it “incredibly straightforward” and “a seamless collaboration,” and said Playhouse Square is updating its 2019 numbers. “2019 is a bit old, folks.” Pancheri said the CFO is closely involved, and Summerfest’s Jared Woods leads the process through marketing data. Summerfest runs two studies, one for the festival and one for its full season, and when multiple groups use a site, they can all contribute data. Baltzer said to be upfront about what you need. “Once you get into the parameters of what we want to do in the study, they’ll lead you, they’ll tell you what they need.”
Audience Q&A
Measuring spending outside the venue. Mariano said the team requests ticket data with ZIP codes, but resellers can skew it, so they compare it with mobile geolocation data. Patrons are split into locals, day-trippers and overnight visitors, since each spends differently. Summerfest runs a detailed on-site patron survey. Playhouse Square doesn’t, though Hassall said, “Not yet.” Because Tourism Economics works with nearly every destination marketing organization, it already knows what an average visitor spends. Pepitone said the Monument’s convention, concert and rodeo crowds each have different spending profiles, and studies also use local hotel and short-term rental rates.
Hassall wants to measure free, non-ticketed events, where people come “grazing in the neighborhood.” Wagner said firms like Arrivalist and Placer can build geofences around an attraction or district to track device movement. “It’s kind of creepy,” Wagner said, though the data doesn’t identify individuals. Pepitone added that the data shows cross-visitation, which often reveals spending “a lot broader than you anticipated.” Pancheri noted every client gets a full report with methodology and details beyond the headline numbers.
When the city doesn’t collect the tax. An attendee said their municipality pushes back because visitor taxes go to the provincial and federal governments. Wagner said the case rests on jobs, local vendors and the multiplier effect. Even without a local tax like Nashville’s, “there’s a whole lot of people in the community who are benefiting from that in a lot of different ways.”
Smaller markets. Mariano said a smaller market can study its whole entertainment industry and compare it to other local industries rather than to bigger cities. Pancheri suggested finding advocates who have “got religion” and offered to brainstorm afterward. Baltzer said that at a previous venue next to a bigger market, bringing the larger city into the effort helped put the venue on the map. Hassall said size doesn’t matter. “I think all of us undersell our own impact without knowing what that impact is,” Hassall said. A study provides “external validation” and “so much more weight and gravitas in your own market.”
What it costs. Mariano said costs depend on scope, but studies typically start around $30,000, with a discount for IEBA members. Hassall said Playhouse Square has earned that back “tenfold, a hundredfold,” calling the benefit “eye-watering.” Baltzer said the Monument can’t do a study every year, so it targets every three to five years. “Hopefully what you’re seeing is your numbers are continually elevating,” Baltzer said. Details on the IEBA program will be posted on the IEBA website.
Key Takeaways
Economic impact studies measure direct, indirect and induced spending, jobs, wages and tax revenue, giving venues hard numbers to back up their value.
Tourism Economics’ past clients have received an estimated $3.6 billion in public and private funding, including $1.2 billion for Nissan Stadium.
Conservative, defensible numbers hold up against skeptical officials.
Cumulative figures let venues and festivals talk about billions, not millions, and sharing the numbers turns staff, vendors and donors into advocates.
Studies have unlocked tax credits, grants, donor renewals, building preservation funds and even infrastructure like sewer service.
Studies typically start around $30,000, IEBA members receive a discount, and repeating them every few years keeps the story current.

